The Cost of Doing Nothing

27 Dec 2024

Share

Falls From Height Are Some Of The Most Common Of All Serious Workplace Injuries

Every day, thousands of workers perform tasks at heights on rooftops, often unaware of the risks they face. When companies prioritize only getting things done quickly, safety on rooftops can sometimes take a back seat. However, overlooking rooftop fall protection isn’t just a minor oversight—it can lead to devastating consequences, both in human and financial terms. This guide explores the hidden costs of neglecting fall protection and outlines the essential steps for creating a safe and compliant rooftop environment.

The Real Cost of Doing Nothing

The initial costs of implementing rooftop fall protection might seem high, but the long-term savings and benefits far outweigh the costs. Failing to implement rooftop fall protection can result in significant financial, legal, and damage to a companies reputation. Here’s why:

The Financial and Legal Impact of Ignoring Rooftop Safety

Accidents resulting from inadequate fall protection can lead to legal issues. Employers are liable for workplace injuries, and lawsuits can drain financial resources. OSHA penalties for non-compliance can reach up to $161,323 per violation, not including the costs of legal fees and potential settlements (OSHA Penalties). According to the Department of Labor and other resources, the estimated revenue required to offset the loss when a fall occurs is $3,000,000. Repeat violations can lead to higher fines and increased scrutiny from regulatory bodies, exacerbating the financial burden.

Worker Compensation Claims

Injuries from falls are among the most common and costly workplace accidents. The National Safety Council reports that slips, trips, and falls cause nearly 20% of all job-related accidents, and the average cost of a workplace injury exceeds $40,000 (NSC Injury Facts). Implementing fall protection can prevent these incidents and the associated compensation claims, protecting your bottom line. Additionally, severe injuries can lead to long-term disability claims, further increasing insurance premiums and long-term costs for the company.

Loss of Productivity

An accident on the job site can halt operations, causing delays and impacting project timelines. Additionally, the morale of the workforce can be affected, leading to decreased productivity. Ensuring a safe working environment fosters a more efficient and motivated team. Frequent accidents can lead to a culture of fear and hesitation, where workers are less likely to perform optimally due to concerns about their safety.

Reputation Damage

News of workplace accidents can tarnish a company’s reputation. Clients and partners are likely to choose competitors with better safety records. Investing in fall protection demonstrates a commitment to employee welfare and corporate responsibility, enhancing your brand’s image. A strong safety record is a valuable asset in competitive markets, attracting potential clients who prioritize worker safety.

The Hierarchy of Fall Protection: A Strategic Approach to Rooftop Safety

Rooftop fall hazards, such as unprotected skylights, pose a significant safety risk to workers. The Hierarchy of Fall Protection provides a structured approach to mitigating these hazards, prioritizing the most effective measures. Below, we apply this framework to the example of skylight protection.

1. Eliminate Hazards
The most effective way to manage a fall hazard is to remove it entirely, eliminating any chance of an incident.
Solution: Remove the skylight and roof over the opening. By eliminating the skylight, the risk of a fall is completely eradicated.

2. Collective Fall Protection
Collective solutions protect all individuals working in the area without requiring active participation from workers. These systems are simple to maintain and comply with safety standards.
Solution: Install a durable skylight screen or a protective railing around the skylight. These collective measures create a physical barrier that prevents falls, ensuring safety for everyone on the rooftop.

3. Work Restraint Systems
Work restraint systems prevent workers from approaching a fall hazard by limiting their movement. These systems are ideal when elimination or collective measures are impractical.
Solution: Use an anchor point designed to keep workers at least 2 feet away from the skylight. This ensures that workers cannot accidentally step onto or near the unprotected skylight.
4. Fall Arrest Systems
Fall arrest systems are designed to stop a worker’s fall in progress, minimizing injury. These systems are used when workers must operate in areas where falls remain a possibility.
Solution: Install an anchor point that allows workers to fall through the skylight but prevents them from impacting the lower level. This setup ensures that the fall is arrested within acceptable force and distance limits.

This systematic approach ensures that hazards are mitigated effectively, prioritizing solutions that provide maximum safety with minimal reliance on personal intervention. By following the Hierarchy of Fall Protection, businesses can create a safer rooftop environment and protect workers from life-threatening risks.

Understanding Rooftop Work Zones and Safety Requirements

The proximity of workers to the roof edge determines the type of protection required. OSHA provides guidelines based on distance from the edge:

Zone 1 (Within 6 feet): Workers performing tasks less than 6 feet from the roof edge must use a guardrail system, a travel restraint, or a fall arrest system.
Zone 2 (6 to 15 feet): Work within this range requires similar fall protection measures, although designated safe areas may be used if the work is temporary or infrequent.
Zone 3 (Beyond 15 feet): For tasks more than 15 feet from the edge, warning lines or designated areas are often permitted, provided that the work is both temporary and infrequent.

Definitions of “Temporary” and “Infrequent” Work:

Temporary: Work that is brief, usually lasting less than two hours and uncomplicated in nature. The work must be of short duration, typically lasting no longer than a "an hour or 2" according to Federal OSHA. The key with temporary work is that the task is simple and can be done in a single trip to the work area, no diagnostic or assessment process and then return with the tools required to complete the work. This reduces exposure to the access point hazards and leading edge hazards by half.
Infrequent: Work performed occasionally, such as once a month or annually, but not as part of daily routines. The work must involve occasional or sporadic access to the surface rather than regular or routine access. Infrequent access is typically in response to a breakdown. Federal OSHA has cited access more than once per month as frequent, but safety experts tend to agree with CAL-OSHA that infrequent should be once per quarter or less. This will limit the number of entries through the access point to below 8 per year.

Access Points, Openings, and the Leading Edge

Rooftop safety is more than just addressing the leading edge. Statistically, more workers fall through skylights than over open roof edges. Traversing the middle of a rooftop often gives workers a false sense of security as they focus on carrying equipment or completing tasks. This misplaced confidence can lead to missteps and falls through unprotected skylight openings, one of the most overlooked yet critical hazards to address. OSHA identifies skylights as rooftop holes, highlighting the importance of treating them as serious risk factors. Solutions such as screens, guardrails, or compliant covers are essential for mitigating these risks.

Access points like ladderways and hatches also represent high-frequency hazards. Ensuring these areas are protected with OSHA-compliant guardrails and self-closing gates is vital for a comprehensive rooftop safety plan. Properly designed access points reduce risks and help maintain safety during routine maintenance and operational tasks.

Slips, trips, and falls account for nearly 20% of workplace accidents, with rooftop falls being a leading cause of severe injuries and fatalities. Beyond the human cost, non-compliance with OSHA standards can lead to significant penalties, increased insurance premiums, operational shutdowns, and damage to a company's reputation. The time and resources required to remedy safety violations disrupt essential maintenance, repair, and operations activities, impacting a company's productivity and bottom line.

Investing in fall protection safeguards both workers and businesses. By addressing all hazards—including access points, openings, and the roof edge—companies create a culture of safety and trust. Proactive safety measures preserve operational efficiency, protect employees, and mitigate liability risks. Contact us to schedule a rooftop safety assessment and take the first step toward a safer, more compliant work environment.

Comprehensive Solutions for Rooftop Fall Protection

No two rooftops are identical, and each requires a tailored approach to ensure safety and compliance. Kee Safety provides a range of solutions that can be customized to meet the specific needs of different building structures:

Kee Guard: A modular guardrail system that protects roof perimeters without penetrating the roof membrane.
Kee Cover: Safety covers for skylights to prevent falls through rooftop openings.
Kee Platform and Kee Step: Solutions that provide safe access over obstacles and height differences on the rooftop.

Safety is Kee, let us help protect your team

Please fill in your details below and we’ll be in touch shortly.

The Cost of Doing Nothing

Falls From Height Are Some Of The Most Common Of All Serious Workplace Injuries